A History teacher educator’s reflections after classroom observations: The need for multi-perspectives, oral history and historiography in a history methodology course
MetadataShow full item record
Given current debates about South Africa’s contested past, how could teacher educators address this issue with preservice teachers so that their historical understanding develops and they present a multi-perspective view of history in practice? The underlying problem this question raises is how to shift teachers’ approaches to history teaching from one that splits “fact” and interpretation in a one-dimensional account, to a multi-perspective view which acknowledges the interrelationship of interpretations and “facts”. This article’s purpose is to reflect on what I learnt for my own practice as a teacher educator after I observed eight practising teachers, who were former preservice teachers, teach an oral history task. The results of this research led me to propose changes to a history methodology course. I suggest firstly that preservice teachers scrutinise claims to “the truth” in oral history accounts through the “sins” of memory, which they use to re-examine “the truth” claims in their personal oral history tasks. Secondly, by exploring major developments in South African historiography, this provides a framework that shows how multi-perspectives arise and how the “politics of interpretation” informs the different “schools” of historiography. This process helps the preservice teachers examine the interrelationship between some of the “big” ideas found in historiography with the “small” ideas in their oral history tasks. It also aims to plant the seeds of doubt about history being a fixed body of knowledge, so that the preservice teachers might present a multi-perspective view of history once they become practising teachers. Adapting this process to their own context could provide a way for teacher educators in other countries to address similar issues with preservice history teachers.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Exploring local histories in the use and appreciation of heritage and history in history curricula. Van Eeden, Elize S (The South African Society for History Teaching (SASHT) under the auspices of the School of Basic Sciences, Vaal Triangle Campus, North-West University, 2010)With the Internet so easily available nowadays, I decided (just for the fun of it but also out of curiosity) to do a Google search to see how many entries I could find for "heritage and history". In a split second no fewer ...
History teachers and the use of History textbooks in Africa – From textbook to 'desa': A personal narrative of teaching History in Tanzania Rushohora, Nancy A (The South African Society for History Teaching (SASHT) under the auspices of the School of Basic Sciences, Vaal Triangle Campus, North-West University, 2015)
The Traditional Health Practitioners Act No. 22 (2007) of South Africa: Its history, resolutions and implementations in perspective (Part 1: History) Louw, Gabriel; Duvenhage, André (Australasian Medical Journal, 2016)Background: Years of South African legislation on traditional healing practices preceded the Traditional Health Practitioners Act (Act No. 22, 2007). The first laws date as far back as 1895. It seems as if the intention ...