Show simple item record

dc.contributor.advisorDe la Harpe, S.P.L.R., Prof
dc.contributor.authorMugadza, W.T.
dc.date.accessioned2018-10-15T10:14:18Z
dc.date.available2018-10-15T10:14:18Z
dc.date.issued2018
dc.identifier.urihttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-4974-2542
dc.identifier.urihttp://hdl.handle.net/10394/31417
dc.descriptionLLD (International Aspects of Law), North-West University, Potchefstroom Campus
dc.description.abstractThis study was motivated by the quest to find new innovative and practical ways of combating public procurement corruption in developing countries to complement the existing measures. This was achieved by comparing three jurisdictions, Hong Kong-China, Botswana and South Africa. The focus was on how each jurisdiction uses the following four measures to curb public procurement corruption: criminal measures; administrative measures; institutional measures and civil activism measures. It was established that Hong Kong uses what this study has classified as the traditional approach of combating public procurement corruption. The traditional approach is characterised by the use of a separate procurement legal framework and a separate corruption legal framework to curb public procurement corruption. Its strengths are in the strict enforcement of criminal measures that are anchored on a robust legal framework, a clear anti-corruption strategy, an independent anti-corruption agency (institutional measure), effective internal oversight and a strong political will. However, the following weaknesses of the traditional approach were identified: over reliance on criminal measures; excessive dependence on one enforcement institution; it neglects the development of administrative measures and has weak civil activism measures. It was established that Botswana uses what this study has classified as the classical approach of combating public procurement corruption. The classical approach is characterised by a procurement legal framework that incorporates very minimum anti-corruption provisions. The anti-corruption provisions in the procurement legislation are enforced by an external institution (the DCEC in the case of Botswana) which relies heavily on the criminal measures. Its strengths are the following: a strong legal framework which provides for a clear anti-corruption strategy; it has anti-corruption units in each Ministry and it has a dedicated Corruption Court. However, the classical approach has the following weaknesses: the anti-corruption agency is not adequately independent as it under the control of the executive (the President in the case of Botswana); lacks effective internal oversight mechanisms; weak political will; neglects the development of administrative measures and civil activism measures are almost non-existent save for the media. It was established that South Africa uses what this study has classified as the traditional cum silo approach of combating public procurement corruption. The traditional cum approach is characterised by multiple procurement legislation which has certain but minimum anti-corruption provisions and a separate corruption legal framework. Multiple anti-corruption agencies are prone to political interference which renders them ineffective and unfit for purpose. Its strength is in the promotion and protection of civil activism measures (right to access information, right to freedom of speech and legal protection of whistle-blowers). Notable weaknesses of the traditional cum silo approach are: the poor enforcement of criminal measures; there is no lead anti-corruption agency that spearheads and coordinates all cases of public procurement corruption; there is no clear anti-corruption strategy; the administrative measures such as debarment are poorly enforced; it has multiple anti-corruption institutions that lack focus and professionalism which results in political manipulation. The thesis concluded by suggesting a new approach, the contemporary approach to combating public procurement corruption which entails the enactment of a single procurement legislation (model law) the Public Procurement and Combating of Public Procurement Corruption Act (hereafter PPCPPC). The contemporary approach advocates for the regulation of public procurement and the combating of public procurement corruption in one legislation. This legislation (PPCPPC) takes into account, the current demands for public procurement as well as future developments of public procurement. These include but are not limited to self-cleaning, cyber-crime and public procurement corruption as well as the role of foreign convictions for debarment purposes. The envisaged PPCPPC will in addition to regulating public procurement, encompass the best criminal measures, administrative measures, institutional measures and civil activism measures. In addition, the contemporary approach through the PPCPPC proposes two new innovations: the corruption clearance certificate and a mandatory anti-corruption clause in all government contracts.en_US
dc.language.isoenen_US
dc.publisherNorth-West Universityen_US
dc.subjectPublic procurementen_US
dc.subjectcombating corruptionen_US
dc.subjectprocurement principlesen_US
dc.subjecttransparencyen_US
dc.subjectaccountabilityen_US
dc.subjectcompetitivenessen_US
dc.subjectfairnessen_US
dc.subjectequalityen_US
dc.subjectintegrityen_US
dc.subjectvalue for moneyen_US
dc.subjectcriminal measuresen_US
dc.subjectadministrative measuresen_US
dc.subjectinstitutional measuresen_US
dc.subjectcivil activism measures traditional approachen_US
dc.subjectclassical approachen_US
dc.subjectcontemporary approachen_US
dc.subjectcorruption clearance certificateen_US
dc.subjectmandatory anti-corruption clauseen_US
dc.subjectself-cleaningen_US
dc.subjectdebarmenten_US
dc.subjectHong Kongen_US
dc.subjectBotswanaen_US
dc.subjectSouth Africaen_US
dc.titleCombating corruption in public procurement in developing countries: a legal analysisen_US
dc.typeThesisen_US
dc.description.thesistypeDoctoralen_US
dc.contributor.researchID11802618 - De la Harpe, Stephanus Petrus Le Roux


Files in this item

Thumbnail

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record